Here in Australia, if you are renting out a property and the tenants completely trash the place or don’t pay their rent on time, you don’t have much legal recourse to evict the vandals promptly. The law is on the side of the tenants. Likewise, as I was recently told, if somebody is being physically aggressive with you, unless you respond within 3 seconds it is you who will be taken to court. I am immediately reminded here of what Wing Chun sifu Gary Lam said: “If you cannot finish the fight in 3 seconds, don’t tell me you are doing self-defence.”
There was an interesting point posted by my Facebook friend Jai Harman, that although grappling on the ground like our Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu friends are fond of doing is extremely dangerous and unwise in a real fight situation (imagine frolicking on the floor trying to choke the assailant while having your skull cracked courtesy of his girlfriend’s creative use of her stiletto heels – true story, by the way), it is still handy to add standing grappling (qin na / 擒拿) to your arsenal of techniques.
I quite agree with Jai and am happy to say that in the line of Yuen Kay San Wing Chun taught in our gwoon we have the full curriculum of close-body fighting and qin na (we call it kum na in Cantonese) thanks to the contributions of the imperial marshal Fung Siu Ching (the famous disciple of Red Boater Dai Fa Mien Kam). But like I always say to our junior students, unless your gung fu is so good that you are superconfident that you can overpower and control your assailant without getting seriously injured yourself (think facing multiple, knife-wielding attackers intent on finishing you off), I would not rely on any technique to merely control the opponent.
Yes — the law is not on your side if you are deemed to have used “excessive force”. As a former policeman who used to train at our gwoon once remarked, using Wing Chun vs aikido or jiu-jitsu would not shine a favourable light on the person defending his life. So what do you do? Try to control your opponent hoping you won’t get sued? Or give it all you’ve got, and go home to your loved ones alive?
It is interesting that Yuen Kay San was in fact a lawyer. One of his combat advices is about pre-emptive striking. Hardly a case of self-defence (more like self-offence) in the legal system of this day and age.
My sifu Yun Hoi will expand…
— Peter
Continue reading →